L'OREAL Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner - Black

This eyeliner is incredible! First of all, it's really easy to apply, it's very smooth and it glides without any problem. Second of all, it doesn't smudge (and I have very watery eyes, it's been very difficult for me to find a good pencil... and I've tried many of them) and it stays on for 12 hours (this is the maximum amount of time that I've had it on, I didn't go for longer so far). So I totally recommend it!

Just loved it, it lasts all day, easy to remove with vaseline.

The pencil itself is long lasting and a good deep colour but it is very soft and breaks easily. Doesn't sharpen very well as it breaks in the sharpener. There are other products available that are just as good for half the price.

Good but not good enough

I bought this over priced eyeliner for one reason only. It stays put. It doesn't. Had it on about an hour then dismayed to see dark shadows under both eyes

Disappointed as this got very good reviews but Smudges quite badly

Muy buen producto

me ha parecido caro, pensaba era lápiz automático

This eye pencil goes on very smoothly and doesn’t tug on the skin. The color shows nicely, and it stays in place for most of the day. Great for everyday makeup.

I really love this liner. The black is so vivid and bold, and it glides on like a charm. It truly stays all day without smudging or smearing, which is rare for something that applies so smoothly. My only small gripe is that I wish the tip were a little sharper for more precise lining. But overall, it does exactly what it says. I love it, intense color, long wear, and effortless application. I love this collection by Loreal, and for the price you you can't go wrong.

This is a good, hardy eyeliner pencil, the kind that you sharpen with a separate sharpener-- not those flimsy ones that you have to turn up, that break all the time. The thickness is perfect, stays put, doesn't smudge, and goes on smooth. I rarely see this one in stores, so I was really happy to find one on here to replace the one I had previously used up. I hope they never stop making this one, because a good eyeliner with all of these qualities is hard to find!