Monster Cookie Peanut Butter, 454 g

I was looking forward to this product but ended up very disappointed with it. When I pulled the container out of the box I noticed that the peanut butter looked runny on the top, which at first I didn’t think too much of as I figured it was just the oil. However once I opened the container I noticed that it was more than just the top. I tried to stir it up but it didn’t help it much. I tasted it and it was horrible. I then looked over the container and noticed the sticker for the expiration date was 1-2023. So I don’t know if it just went bad early or what but I just threw it away. I won’t be buying anymore of these.

I have used a lot of protein infused nut butters over the years (Nuts N More, Legendary Foods, etc), so this type of product is a staple for me, especially in off-season where my calorie needs are a higher to fuel growth. Fit Butters is a new-comer in the space and being one that loves trying new flavors and products for things I use, this was a must buy. I like that Fit Butters not only has a variety of flavors, but also has multiple iterations using different nuts as the bases of the product. Being allergic to almonds, it is nice to have other options so the peanut butter ones are my go to and being a fan of cookies (but rarely eating them), Cookie Madness was an easy choice to try out. The texture and consistency is what you would expect from a fresh-ground, natural nut butter as the oil does separate, so a quick stir upon receiving the product and you're good to go. Upon tasting, texture is fantastic, but for those new to protein infused nut butters it does have a little bit of a thicker consistency which is the nature of such a product but doesn't hinder the taste at all. It has a very rich, roasted peanut base with just the right amount of sweetness coming through, attributed to the protein they infused it with (in this case Purus Labs Keto Feed Oatmeal Cream Pie flavor) and the added M&M bits. and all combine to make a flavor that is spot on for a rich, monster cookie flavor (oatmeal, M&M/chocolate cookie). Nutrition wise, this is on point for what it is...it does have a slightly higher calorie content due to the additional protein and inclusions (M&M/chocolate), but at the end of the day...it is a nut butter and if calorie dense foods are a concern, then this isn't the type of product for you....and if you're complaining that it has a higher calorie count that the generic, store bought garbage like Skippy or Jiff, then you have bigger problems in your daily nutrition to address and some education about nutrition to attain. Overall, this products flavor, nutrition profile and consistency are spot on and i would highly recommend this product. No complaints here except for my jar is empty :D

My daughter had purchased some Nerdy Nuts and it was absolutely delicious. I purchased the FIT product because it had less sugar and I am diabetic. When I opened the container of the monster cookie flavor, I was met with a runny, greasy mess. I gave it the benefit of the doubt and promptly tried stirring it up. There was a big clump of matter at the bottom that would not stirred into the oily peanut butter. I went ahead and tasted it and was horrified at the taste. The product is oily, greasy and has a bitter flavor to it. I threw the first container away. I figured I would return the other two containers that were unopened, but was unable to do so, because Amazon does not return food products. A huge waste of money, and a big disappointment!

Tried 4 flavors and none of them are great. Taste nothing like the pictured flavors. Obviously wan’t expecting it would taste like candy, but something just seems off with it. I prefer regular natural peanut butter over these fit butters at 1/4 of the price.

When I got it I thought oh no. It was an oily mess. I stirred it and put it in the refrigerator. It is so much better cold. It stays blended and does not separate. I've just been eating it with a spoon. But bought some apples and will try them together. I like the m&m's, and cookie chunks in it. Good stuff.