The Map That Changed the World: William Smith and the Birth of Modern Geology (P.S.)

Simon Winchester, trained as a geologist, is a bit fascinated with catastrophes. He has written about the eruption of Krakatoa (Krakatoa) and the San Francisco earthquake of 1906 (A Crack In the Edge of the World) along with many other books on diverse subjects (The Professor and the Madman, for instance, which describes one of the more intriguing contributors to the Oxford English Dictionary). But The Map That Changed the World must, for him, have been a special endeavor as William Smith the creator of the map is especially revered by the English and resides, along with Hutton and Lyell in their geological pantheon, which is obviously crowded. The map, the first truly geological map, covers most of the British Isles and looks remarkably similar to current U.S. geological maps, especially in the use of myriad colors to indicate different formations. (The word "geology" was first used in its modern sense in 1735.) Today, the eight foot by six map hangs behind blue curtains in Burlington House on the north side of Piccadilly. The map Smith created "...was conceived, imagined, begun, undertaken, and continued and completed [in 1815] against all odds by just one man." It was drawn when many in Britain still were convinced that James Ussher's assertion that the earth was created at 9 A.M. on October 23, 4004 B.C was true. It is even more remarkable because Smith lived a wretched life. He was a simple, self-taught, country man with a very sick wife who went bankrupt and became homeless shortly after he finished the map. But both the industrial and agrarian revolutions were at hand. Smith's initial interest was sparked by the sea-urchin shaped stone used as a "pound" stone on English scales. He was hired as a surveyor's helper working in the coal mines in Somerset. Every time he went down he looked at what we would now call the stratigraphic column. "The pattern, Smith saw, was always the same, in mine after mine after mine: from top to bottom, Sandstone, Siltstone, Mudstone, Nonmarine Band, Marine Band, coal, Seat Earth, and then again Sandstone, Siltstone, Mudstone, on and on." He wondered whether there might not be a way of predicting what lay where and, indeed, a way of drawing a guide to what lay below. And because, in part, that he wondered about this he was selected to be the surveyor for the Somerset Canal, which, in effect, opened the earth to him. Once opened, he started comparing the facies at different places. He investigated two that were identical for all practical purposes, except that they had been deposited at different elevations, as much as hundreds of feet. The color, chemistry and grain size was identical, but the fossils were different: "Every single one of the specimens of one kind of fossil might be the same throughout one bed, but would be subtly different from those of the same kind of fossil found in another bed." The map followed. Smith saw a soil map in the County Agricultural Report showing"... the geographical extent of each of the various soils and types of vegetation that were known in the countryside around Bath. His first map and the oldest of true geological maps depicted the geology around Bath, published in 1799. He drew and dictated the stratigraphic column that was the basis of the map at a dinner with friends. That drawing is preserved by the Geological Society of London today. However, shortly thereafter, Smith was fired by the canal company for unknown reasons, found himself with too big of a mortgage and eventually ended up in debtor's prison. Winchester describes the English legal system in as great detail as he does the making of Smiths map. The details of the map and the friends who helped Smith with it are captivating and represent a great deal of scholarship and digging. Smith got it done, but his debts were not paid and so he ended up in jail. Upon his release he found employment with a William Fitton who eventually realized that he was the Smith who had prepared the map, which had become very well known although controversial. Eventually, Smith was recognized for the map he had prepared. If Winchester has left out any historical geologist of note in telling the heroic, tragic and then heroic again events of Smith's life, it is not readily apparent. Winchester is a felicitous writer who has told the life of one of the more interesting members of England's scientific community along with the side notes that reinforces the opprobrium that "there will always be an England."

William Smith is a long way from being a household name, but his work represented some of the most important geological investigations of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. In "The Map That Changed the World: William Smith and the Birth of Modern Geology," Simon Manchester tells the story of the unlikely hero of British canal surveyor and builder William Smith who realized that he could map the location of fossils and begin to deduce the nature of geology, the age of the Earth, the upheavals of ice ages and other formation events, and the manner in which the British Isles became the British Isles. Smith labored for decades on his map, laboriously treading the hinterlands of Britain mapping terrain, elevations, rock formations, and the like. In the end he produced the 1815 8.5- by 6-foot, hand-colored map entitled "A Delineation of the Strata of England and Wales." Others recognized it for it was, a masterpiece, but the bourgeois of the Geological Society of London refused to acknowledge his accomplishment and a cabal kept him from receiving the honors Smith believed were his due. Smith had the map's key discoveries stolen from him, he failed to realize the remuneration he hoped would accrue from its success, and he ended up in debtor's prison. As if that was not enough, a decade of hardship, homelessness, and other travail followed. Not until 1831, when Smith was 61 years old, did he receive veneration from the Geographical Society, and then gained a pension from King William IV to end his penuriousness. This book is a fine reading experience, and represents some of the best recent historical literary work of the past decade. The author, Benjamin Winchester, offers a compelling portrait of this individual and the map that he created, arguing that both represent the bedrock of the modern science of geology. Interestingly, this book helps to get to the complex question of the age of the Earth and counteracts the arguments being made for a young Earth using the dating scheme of Bishop Ussher limiting it to about 6,000 years. While advocates of young Earth creationism often argue that the dating of the Earth to millions of years of age were essentially arguments drawn up to buttress Darwinism, William Smith's activities at dating the age of the Earth and the development of the modern science of geology actually predate "On the Origin of Species by several decade. "The Map That Changed the World" documents how this came about in great detail and with a storyteller's flair for detail and narrative. There is no question but that William Manchester has captured the essence of a fascinating character in the history of science. But I must offer a caution, and this is the reason that I give this book four rather than five stars; this work is more a literary work than a sophisticated work in the history of science. If one is seeking an extensively documented, historiographically sophisticated exploration of the origins and development of the science of geology there are other books which engage the scholarly discourse. What this is, and it really doesn't pretend to be anything more than this, is an elegantly written, accessible recitation of a fascinating and important life and set of accomplishments. On that basis it is quite excellent. That is really quite a lot, but I would have liked more.

Amazing book. I was not particularly interested in geology, but now I am! The story of what William Smith learned about the geology under Britain, relying in part on which fossils he found where, while digging canals, is amazing. But we also get the bio of Smith and how little credit he got (and how others stole his work) -- spent a couple of years in debtors' prison! And the development of science, including the science of geology, which he practically invented -- mesmerizing. I immediately bought more of Winchester's books. He is a master storyteller.

Over all, it was a well written and informative book. However, the book left me with a sour taste in many places. The author was quick to point out over and over again that what William Smith discovered disproved the Bible. Which it did nothing of the sort. There are many brilliant geologist today who see the same evidence that Smith saw and still believe in a young earth and still believe the Bible. Overall, great history and great reading. But the author's snarky commentary was quite annoying.

Simon Winchester is a great author. I read his books about the great San Francisco Earthquake of 1906 and the eruption of Krakatoa..5 stars..see my reviews. The Map that Changed the World is about William Smith the "Father of Geology" and the Great Map of England's Geology that he created. We see William as a young man as a surveyor of coal mines and canals in England in the early 19th century as England was getting a great industrialization. He temporarily has a very good income but over stretched his finances, buying a large estate with a large mortgage, renting an expensive apartment, opening up a mine that fails and marrying a woman who develops heath problems and severe mental illnesses. He is fired from his job and tries getting smaller temporary jobs but eventually is thrown in "Debtors Prison". He is financially ruined. William through the decades learns about the different strata layers of the earth and the different fossils that are in certain layers. He learns the layers represent different ages of the earth and are very, very old.He believes much, much older than anyone thought. He battles people who for religious reasons believe that God created the earth in 1 day and the earth is way less than 10.000 years old. Today by carbon radioactive isotope dating, we know that some of these rock layers are hundreds of millions of years old and older. In William's early 1800th days no one knew this. Also a rich, snob member of the "Geologist Society" steals William's geology data and plagiarizes his great Map of England's underground Geology. A friend takes financially destroyed William and his wife in. Eventually the snobs in the Geology Society lose their power and William is recognized as the true "Father of Geology and the true creator of the great Map of England's Geology. William is given the ultimate recognition by his peers, the gold Wollaston Medal. Eventually, William gets his true Great colored Map of England's Geology printed and copies sold. He is given an Irish honorary doctorate degree and a $100LB pension from the English government. Finally he has the recognition as the "Father of English Geology and the creator of the Great Colored Large Map of English Geology. I won't ruin the ending for you. A great ending. Anyone interested in the history of Geology, fossils or map creation will enjoy this book plus you will learn a little about the different Earth layers and where some different kinds of fossils are located in the different layers/ages. I developed a lot of empathy for William Smith and gave a small cheer when he eventually gets his recognition as "Father of Geology", and the creator of the Great Colored large Map of English Geology a revolutionary breakthrough showing the underground geology layers that changed people's thinking about how the earth rock/layers were formed, the rock layers ages ,and life at differnt ages on earth) and happiness. 5 stars and recommended. Another winner by Simon Winchester!

The beginnings of geology as a science and discipline. Possibly an exaggeration, this story lays out the birth of geology in England. The focus is on William Smith, self made man, who is part of the creation of geological studies as part of his trade as a kind of travelling engineer consultant at the time of the Napoleonic wars. I had little idea what was in this book until I began reading. I'm glad I had lived in England in the 1960s. Descriptions of countryside and general map layouts in the book made more sense than if my knowledge of England was based on some PBS documentaries.

This book reminded me of why I took a degree in Geology so long, long ago. That is, it reminded me of the sense of excitement that I once felt for the wonders of the earth. This is not some dry-as-dust history, for you actually feel like you are accompanying Smith on his travels through England as he laid the foundations for the modern science of geology. For that is what William "Strata" Smith was- the founder of modern Geology, and the first working field geologist. Sure, there had been academic and aristocratic dilettantes working in the field before Smith, but it was he who actually got his hands dirty and climbed down into the mines and canal excavations. It was he who formulated the Law of Superposition, and if I am not mistaken, the Law of Faunal Succession. It was Smith who was the first to actually go out (with a pack horse) and first correlate sections, measure strike and dip, and use index fossils to differentiate strata. And, of course, he was the first to visualise how to depict the three-dimensional structure of the earth on a geologic map. Anyone who has tried to work steadily in the field will recognize and sympathize with Smith's ups and downs. He rose from very humble rural beginnings to essentially educate himself and then secure a successful and well-respected career, only to end up essentially homeless for a decade and then in a debtor's prison. He saw his work stolen by others. It was only in his later years that his reputation and fortunes were reestablished. Anyone familiar with the oil patch will recognize this pattern.... Oh yes, and the snobbery and elitism of academic geologists for those who actually work for a living will also strike a familiar note. I have one small complaint with this otherwise excellently written book. The author mentions the Enclosure Acts while trying to explain Smith's village background in the 18th century. He makes it sound like the Acts were instituted by Parliament purely to provide for the more efficient farming, if not beautification, of the English countryside. Anyone who is familiar with Enclosure (and not trying to rewrite history) knows that this was a colossal land-grab by landed gentry to throw the poor off of commonly held village lands. It also served to make the rural poor desperate enough to work in the hellish mines and mills of the early industrial revolution....

My wonderful book club is fond of taking field trips, and so when one member suggested "Longitude" we knew that a trip to the Royal Observatory in Greenwich was inevitable, despite the distance from Tidewater Virginia. A wandering member was e-mailed to meet us in London for the occasion,and he quickly wrote back saying that "Longitude" was a guy book and a disappointment, and begged us to read "The Map That Changed The World" in addition to if not instead of the former. So we did and he was right. "Longitude" was an o.k. quick read, but did not measure up to the hype which suggested that Harrison had dicovered longitude or at least "solved the greatest scientific problem of his time." How disappointing to realize that astronomers had long before figured out the measurment system; what Harrison did was develop the chronometer, a dependable clock which would give reliable time readings during the longest sea voyage. A brilliant man, indeed a genius of clockmaking, and we look forward to actually seeing H-1, H-2 and H-3. But... Now William Smith, there was a genius! He solved a scientific problem that no one even knew existed. If he didn't discover, he at least uncovered (sorry) the science of geology. It seems almost not to be believed that several hundred years after the timing of the orbits of the moons of Jupiter was known to astronomers,the strata that make up the layers of our terrestial orb were unimagined. Seen, of course, by miners, but never even thought of as stages of the creation of our world as we know it. Fascinating subject, fascinating book. And if they will let us in, we will go to Burlington House and ask to have the curtains pulled.

En otras partes he leído que se aproxima a una hagiografía de William Smith, y es cierto que en ocasiones lo parece. Sin embargo está muy bien escrito y cumple perfectamente la misión de recuperar la memoria de un pionero de la geología que acometió en solitario un trabajo de increíble magnitud y transcendencia. Lectura muy recomendable

Not being from the geological background makes the terms and the concepts a bit difficult to understand but a really nice read in terms of the work and the dedication required to achieve success in science.

A fascinating tale of the invention of the science of geology. Interesting story for anyone interested in natural history

A very well researched book on William Smith, the man who made the first geological map. Riveting reading for those interested in geology.

A book on fossils and the establishment of the science of geology - a fascinating and compulsive read - you must be joking! But Simon Winchester recounts the original thought and breakthrough that William Smith made in the late 1700's that became not just the science of geology but provided the basis that helped Charles Darwin formulate his ideas. And he does it in such an entertaining way. Andrew Smith's great breakthrough was his realisation that all rocks laid down as sediments at a particular time and in a particular place are laid down with the same characteristics and the same fossils always appear in the same stratigraphical order. Therefore by noting the fossils found, he could forecast the order of strata beneath them and so produce a geological map. And he went on to geologically map the whole of the British Isles, producing his masterpiece in 1815. He also realised that the more recent strata contained fossils that appeared to be higher forms of life than the fossils in strata lower down and hence provided the evidence that creation was not exactly 6,000 years ago when all species were simultaneously created as was the prevailing belief. Smith recognised and produced the evidence that life far older than mankind had once existed on the planet. But what makes the book so readable is the story of William Smith's life set in the social history of the time. He was from a lower class who learned his trade as an apprentice land surveyor at the times of the enclosures, then as a mining surveyor and then a surveyor for the canal boom. His theories were developed from his observations and his practical experience. But not being a member of the aristocracy created an almost insurmountable barrier to the acceptance of his ideas and his involvement in the burgeoning societies for scientific development. But there were well connected doctors / MP's / vicars - Joseph Townsend and Benjamin Richardson - who recognised Smith's brilliance and assisted him to formulate and write down his ideas. And particularly Sir Joseph Banks a prominent member of the aristocracy who sponsored him. But he remained unrecognised and in deep financial trouble for much of his life - 30 nights in a debtors prison - all his possessions taken - his outstanding fossil collection sold to pay his bills. But fortunately in his old age, the new more enlightened society did recognise him as one of the most significant men of the 19th century and gave him the honours and respect he deserved.