Brothers (2004) [DVD]

This is a great film. Slow-readers should be warned that it has subtitles and might want to go for the 2009 US re-make. I'm afraid to watch the re-make because this one was so good, I fear I can only be disappointed. This is by Suzanne Bier. . People who thought Things We Lost in the Fire was a pretty fair film (same director) who is a great director. All her films are interesting (with the exception of (Things We Lost in the Fire). Her film Love is all You Need was A-1. This one is intense, so if you all you want from a film is entertainment, be forewarned. If you don't have a lump in your throat at some point in this film, see your therapist.

While I stumbled upon this wonderful movie because I was looking for other movies with Connie Nielsen, I can only agree with other reviewers. The movie is everything they say it is and more. As a veteran who served and has spent time in VA hospitals, I can tell you this movie hit home. My only wish is that the movie would come out in an English dubbed version so that the movie might garner greater exposure to the general public. If more people saw this movie they would by sheer exposure learn something about the realities of Afghanistan/Middle East politics and their effects on all humans lives. Update--1 July 2008: If this review was not helpful to you, I would appreciate learning the reason(s) so I can improve my reviews. My goal is to provide help to potential buyers, not get into any arguments. So, if you only disagree with my opinion, could you please say so in the comments and not indicate that the review was not helpful. Thanks.

In Cinema there are techniques that make the film - guide the story; the most useful of these are subtle and unobtrusive, usually the efforts of the Director. It is the case with this film that the story appears clear and whole near the conclusion, to which we have been led without spectacular or unnecessary pathos. In this case emotions triumph character so skillfully we must reflect on the movie to find the several beautiful connections. A point can be made the story might have ended ten minutes earlier with good effect. But, in reflection (which a good film fosters), the message of human triumphs and frailties outlasts any minor desires a viewer may wish for the characters. I give it four stars because it is NOT a tale of brothers, even though they contrast in accomplishment. And because there is no message (though there is no rule there should be) but that mankind is an often fragile being, strong one moment and broken the next. All the acting is superb - and the children are precious. The CD I received has several choices for subtitles - and the key to seeing English subs is to highlight "off" in the menu.

DEFINITELY a Scandinavian (BROODING) film. The acting is good, but the movie just is not anything special. I would not recommend it. The American version was done in 2010. It's not an especially good movie, either--with the exception of Toby Maguires performance. It really surprised me. Very Good. Very Chilling.

The Danish edition of this film is quite amazing. This earlier edition of Brothers is much an improvement over the American remake with Tobey Maguire (whose efforts on screen are intense enough). This earlier film is the one to see.

Have purchased two separate dvds of this movie from two different Amazon sellers. There are 3 language subtitle choices, English (of course) is one of them. My remote will underline French & Spanish - and the subtitles will operate. The 'English' choice - this choice 'cannot be underlined' = therefore does not operate. It is not my player ! I have two German movies, the English subtitles work for them. Just mentioning this fact in case anyone is interested ? And, I'm scratching my head because - none of the above 18 reviewers have had this problem. My dvd player is a TOSHIBA HD ... less than a year old, works fine on every other dvd I own.

I like Connie Neilsen, but the overall acting and production and the story line are all weak.

I started not to watch this movie when I saw it had subtitles but I'm glad I took the time to get into it. The acting was wonderful and the story was heartfelt. I would highly recommend this movie.

DVD (Neuware) kam in einwandfreiem Zustand originalverpackt, d.h. in Folie eingeschweißt bei mir an. Bin sehr zufrieden mit dieser Bestellung. Vielen Dank an den Verkäufer. Zum Film: Ein großartiger Film mit grandiosen Schauspielern! Absolut empfehlenswert!

Came across this movie after enjoying Connie Nielsen's strong, no-nonsense performances as a policewoman in Special Victims Unit and a military policewoman in Basic. Her character in Brothers is an ordinary, loving wife and mother who endures the agony of the reported death of her husband in Afghanistan and has to pick up the pieces for the sake of her children and grieving in-laws. Unlike in her previous roles where her strength comes from her badge, gun or military rank, in this film it is the love for her children and family which gives her the determination to carry on. Her portrayal of putting a brave face on grief is wonderfully subtle yet utterly convincing. The sub-plot of what actually happened to her husband in Afghanistan is equally heart-wrenching to watch (as well as a timely reminder that the Americans are not the only troops in Afghanistan!) He is a good man,a loving husband,son and father,a responsible soldier placed in a situation where the only way to survive is to carry out an unimaginably horrific act that goes against every aspect of his character. The consequences of the choice he is forced to make will change the lives of everybody in the film and the "what would you do in that situation" question haunted me long after the film was over. As well as fantastic acting and gripping plotlines, this film is beautifully shot - from Afghanistan sunsets and sand dunes to the Scandinavian designer chic of the family home in Denmark, a visual feast. Lovely movie on so many levels. Have no intention of ever watching the Hollywood remake - couldn't bear to see what they've done to it!

アフガニスタンやイラクに従軍したアメリカ兵がトラウマを背負ってうつ病や自殺をするケースが後を断ちませんがこの映画の兵士もトラウマを背負って家族や兄弟に冷たく当たる姿は見ていて辛いです。 あの後、兵士はどうなるのでしょうか? そんな時こそ妻や兄弟が支えてくれればなぁと期待せずにはいられません。

Buenas interpretaciones. Cine europeo con mayúsculas. Historia interesante, que pone de manifiesto que en la idílica sociedad nórdica no todo es perfecto. Muy recomendable. Y el precio es genial.

Questo film è stato capace di trasmettermi nel profondo dell'anima il senso dell'inutilità delle guerre soprattutto quelle che oggi vogliono quasi "ripulirsi" con la proposta di "civilizzare" popoli diversi dai nostri..