Unfathomable

The is a co-operative game with a hidden traitor mechanics. I have two members of my family that hate traitor mechanics because it feels like they are lying, but with this game you can reveal any time you want. This creates less pressure. The game is very balanced. It usually takes us 4 hours to finish with the longest being 6 hours. The board is gorgeous. The plastic molds are good quality and the same with the cards. The first couple of times we lost to the deep but then we learned how to beat them. Certain characters work well together.

Unfathomable is a captivating strategy game that offers a challenging and immersive experience for teens and adults alike. Set in the Arkham Horror universe, this hidden traitor board game keeps players engaged with its blend of strategy and intrigue. One of the game's strengths is its depth and complexity, providing a rich gaming experience that unfolds over multiple playthroughs. The hidden traitor mechanic adds an extra layer of tension and suspense, keeping players on their toes as they navigate alliances and suspicions. However, the learning curve for Unfathomable can be steep. New players may find it challenging to grasp all the rules and intricacies initially, leading to longer playtimes as everyone becomes familiar with the mechanics. Despite this initial hurdle, the game's depth and replayability make it a rewarding choice for those willing to invest time in mastering its strategies. Once players overcome the learning curve, Unfathomable offers hours of fun and strategic gameplay. Overall, Unfathomable earns a four-star rating for its engaging gameplay and thematic depth, with the caveat that it may require patience and multiple playthroughs to fully appreciate.

Love this game. Enough content to have fun but not too heavy. Very good mechanics and of course a hidden traitor or two. We have a great time every time we play it

Unfathomable is an immersive and intense board game that brings players into a thrilling tale of deception, survival, and strategy. 1. Engrossing Theme and Storyline: The game’s setting aboard a doomed ship in the Lovecraftian universe is incredibly atmospheric. The rich narrative and detailed artwork pull players into a world of mystery and horror. The thematic elements are woven seamlessly into the gameplay, making each session feel like a captivating story. 2. Strategic Depth: Unfathomable offers a deep and complex strategic experience. Players must work together to manage resources, fend off threats, and uncover hidden traitors among the crew. The balance between cooperation and suspicion adds layers of strategic decision-making, keeping players engaged and on their toes. 3. High-Quality Components: The game components are top-notch, from the detailed miniatures to the sturdy game board and cards. The visual design and quality of materials enhance the overall gaming experience, making it a joy to play and explore. 4. Tension and Suspense: One of the game’s strongest points is its ability to generate tension and suspense. The hidden traitor mechanic keeps everyone guessing and creates an atmosphere of paranoia and distrust. This makes for an exciting and unpredictable gameplay experience, where alliances are tested, and every move is scrutinized. 5. Replayability: With different roles, scenarios, and outcomes, Unfathomable offers high replayability. Each game feels unique, with new challenges and dynamics emerging based on player actions and decisions. This ensures that players will want to return to the game time and time again. Minor Drawbacks: 1. Complexity for New Players: The game’s rules and mechanics can be daunting for newcomers. The learning curve is steep, and it may take a few playthroughs for players to fully grasp the intricacies of the game. However, for those willing to invest the time, the complexity becomes a rewarding aspect. 2. Game Length: Unfathomable can be quite lengthy, often running several hours per session. While this adds to the depth and immersion, it may be a drawback for those looking for quicker games or for groups with limited time. Planning ahead for longer sessions can help mitigate this issue. 3. Player Count Sensitivity: The game shines best with a full group of players, as the social dynamics and hidden traitor mechanics are most effective with higher player counts. While it’s still enjoyable with fewer players, the experience is richer and more engaging with a larger group. 4. The characters have a decent amount of backstory, but they come across very modern and very generic. Overall, Unfathomable is a deeply engaging and thematically rich board game that offers a thrilling blend of strategy, cooperation, and deception. Its immersive storyline and high replayability make it a standout choice for fans of horror and complex board games. Despite minor drawbacks, it delivers an unforgettable and suspenseful gaming experience. Highly recommended for those seeking a challenging and atmospheric adventure!

A must have for a collector of fantasy flight games

Nice theme

FFG is slowly winning me over with the new Descent, Arkham (board game, I’m not nuts!), and this surprisingly well-done mashup of traitor games and the tight action economy of their other coop titles. It’s like Dead of Winter and Mansions of Madness had a baby. A fun baby. Never played BSG, but this is apparently a reskin of a much-loved game transported to their Arkham Files world. But this time we have some new faces, which is nice. I’ve got nothing against Jenny the dilettante chick and the hobo with the dog guy, but seeing them turn up in every game gets a little old. Their miniatures are hit or miss; Mansions’ are terrible, new Descent’s are amazing. These are somewhere in between. The Deep Ones are meh but the two big monsters look great. I’ve seen this exact art of them in several other games but having them as big miniatures is a ton of fun. Some people have complained about the hodgepodge of art styles. While it’s true that the ship illustration on the board itself has a “bad Sketchup paint over” vibe, the card art and manual design is so insanely tasty that I found the game extremely nice to look at on balance. Be warned though, this is not Werewolf or even Dead of Winter-level gaming. There’s a good amount of stuff going on and keeping track of all the mechanics in effect and actions available to you is going to be a struggle if you’re not fairly deep into board gaming already. That said, there’s no reason you and/or your loved ones can’t learn and this would be a great place to start. Keep up the good work, FFG!

Big fan of Mansions of Madness. Got invited to play this with some friends. I very much like that it's a sped up easier version of Mansions, I've legit had a 7 hour mansions game on numerous occasions. We ended up having two traitors from the beginning so we never had a chance, didn't even get halfway thru the game before the boat sank. We knew who one traitor was but the second one blew our mind because my fiance played so well we didn't even know there was a second one. He got himself thrown in the brig and his captain status removed (and given to me so I looked sus). And stayed there the whole time sabotaging. The owner of the game is a cop and watching him go through an absolute existential crisis and clearly wondering about his career choice upon reveal had me immediately buying this game because it was DELIGHTFUL.