A Complete Guide To Volume Price Analysis

The book has great content but unfortunately the charts are worthless and very confusing. Not only that the charts are black and white but The back ground of each example chart is black and all candlesticks have the same color whether a bullish or bearish candle. I don’t understand why will an author with such great and valuable knowledge to relay to the learner would do so on a black and white book with very poor and unclear charts. I suggest to boost the price on the book and make it colored so we can learn what is being taught

confusing graphs without coloring on the candles or volume. you cant understand anything..

Es uno de los mejores libros para leer el mercado y hacer trading, aunque la impresión es en blanco y negro y las gráficas no se leen muy bien. Así que recomiendo en versión digital.

Excelente

tres bien!

TLDR: 187 page book for $32 CAD that could have been 100 pages shorter if edited critically. Real-world charts are very difficult to interpret in the print edition. I read it all; cover-to-cover. Volume Price Analysis would benefit enormously from an editor with a critical eye, to cut the page count down to about 1/2 - 1/3 and use the extra paper for intelligible charts. From chapter 9 onwards the real charts in the practical examples are incredibly difficult to decipher. The images are grayscale and the author has chosen a solid black background. Distinguishing between something as simple as a green candle and a red candle is a challenge. In some cases the annotations are so pixelated you can barely read them; and at other times may point to wicks that may or may not actually be there. As an optimist my mind immediately went to - no worries, I can just look the data up on my own charting platform and reconstruct them myself; however, this isn't possible as the original chart text may as well have been written in cuneiform, the dates aren't obvious, and the great George Smith is long deceased. The sections with practical examples would be incredibly valuable to readers if more care had been taken in editing and reviewing this book. In some cases, it appears as though an attempt was made, e.g. situating the chart annotations in a white box before overlaying them on the the black background, but this is inconsistent at best. I'll give Anna and the reviewers handing out the "Glowing" 5 star reviews the benefit of the doubt that they may have been reading the kindle edition which might not suffer from the chart issues I mention above. Unfortunately the challenges don't end there though. If you've ever pondered: could VPA work on any instrument? in any market? in any timeframe? You'll have your answer; you'll read it over and over again until you're repeating it in your sleep. The amount of flowery, prosaic, completely unneccessary filler language and analogy you'll read will leave you double-checking whether Charles Dickens was the author, and being paid by the word. When I finished, I had to double-check the Amazon ratings I'd first considered when purchasing the book (72% 5 stars / ~1,500 reviews / 4.5). It left me scratching my head, and wondering if I'd received an old edition, or a photocopy of the real thing.