





desertcart.com: Reading Greek: Text and Vocabulary: 9780521698511: Joint Association of Classical Teachers: Books Review: An excellent text! - "Reading Greek" (RG) is an excellent two- or three-volume text (depending on whether or not you get the "Independent Study Guide", [ISG] a MUST for self-study). This text is designed along lines similar to those of recent Latin textbooks (e.g., the Oxford Latin Course, the Cambridge Latin Course) and rather different from earlier Greek grammars and textbooks. The student is immediately immersed in a story designed to engage interest, but this "created Greek" gives way, little by little, to the real Greek of the Classics, ultimately the major point of learning Greek at all. The reading material has two different vocabulary lists: one for reading comprehension which need not be memorized, and a second (shorter) list of words to be memorized. With frequent rereading of the passages, however, the student will pick up more of the material in the first list simply by dint of exposure. The "Grammar and Exercises" (GE) text is carefully coordinated with RG so that the student's grammatical knowledge grows apace as he encounters new structures in the reading passages. This is an ambitious text in some ways, but I do not think this is a negative. Grammar is well explained but advances rather rapidly (e.g., contract verbs are introduced immediately after presentation of "normal" verbs, imperatives are introduced, 1st- and 2nd-declension nouns and adjectives are presented...all in Chapter 1!), but the presentations are clear with multiple exercises to drill the student's mastery. If working without a teacher, I advise that the self-studier take his time. The chapters are rather long to begin with, and all will be well if the student simply paces himself reasonably. I do agree with another reviewer up to a point: those who are absolute beginners in language study will find the text challenging. Even a casual knowledge of another inflected language (e.g., Latin, Russian, or even German) will be immensely helpful, especially at the outset. As the author observed in his preface, the traditional classical education usually presumed a knowledge of Latin before the student embarked on Greek, but this is no longer so. Greek is a beautiful, marvelous language, but not an easy one, which is perhaps partly why the rewards for learning it are so great. Consistency and pacing are the key to progress. The "Independent Study Guide" mentioned above is extremely valuable. It not only presents good ideas for study but, most importantly, has a key to all the exercises as well as an English translation of all the reading passages. Even working with an experienced teacher in a classroom, the ISG is a huge help for the learner and should be purchased. There is also an audio CD of the reading passages. In all, an excellent and challenging text for the student who wants to make good strides towards reading real Classical Greek. Review: Great book for actually reading. - If you're like me and you came from the soul-crushing world of pointless grammar-translation and are in the comprehensible input Copernican revolution, you'll love this book. I recommend it equally with Athenaze. Because language is primarily an auditory phenomenon, and language is learned via muscle memory and earworms (not via grammar -- just ask any child), you need to listen to it. So, either get the CDs too or do Athenaze + Luke Ranieri's YouTube channel to get the ancient sounds down. Then, read this one out loud. Staring at a text has very limited usefulness. There's a grammar book that comes with it, which can be helpful every few pages; but, your primary focus must be reading and training your brain to handle the onslaught of words. If you don't do that, you'll be in the pointless model of looking for subjects, verbs, modifiers, and parsing words -- which never works in the real world: "I'm sorry, can you repeat what you just said. I was looking for the subject." The progression in this book + Athenaze will train you to be OK to wait for the verb, subject, modifiers, etc. This is the primary skill needed in reading. Ignoring this is why some people call reading "advanced", when it's really the first step. Just read a clause (at normal speed). Didn't get it? Do it again (AT. NORMAL. SPEED). Let your brain do the heavy lifting. Don't know a word? This book has a super generous glossary with every block of text.
| ASIN | 0521698510 |
| Best Sellers Rank | #70,765 in Books ( See Top 100 in Books ) #123 in Foreign Language Instruction (Books) #84,807 in Literature & Fiction (Books) |
| Customer Reviews | 4.5 4.5 out of 5 stars (242) |
| Dimensions | 6.85 x 0.72 x 9.72 inches |
| Edition | 2nd |
| ISBN-10 | 9780521698511 |
| ISBN-13 | 978-0521698511 |
| Item Weight | 1.4 pounds |
| Language | English |
| Print length | 318 pages |
| Publication date | July 30, 2007 |
| Publisher | Cambridge University Press |
R**A
An excellent text!
"Reading Greek" (RG) is an excellent two- or three-volume text (depending on whether or not you get the "Independent Study Guide", [ISG] a MUST for self-study). This text is designed along lines similar to those of recent Latin textbooks (e.g., the Oxford Latin Course, the Cambridge Latin Course) and rather different from earlier Greek grammars and textbooks. The student is immediately immersed in a story designed to engage interest, but this "created Greek" gives way, little by little, to the real Greek of the Classics, ultimately the major point of learning Greek at all. The reading material has two different vocabulary lists: one for reading comprehension which need not be memorized, and a second (shorter) list of words to be memorized. With frequent rereading of the passages, however, the student will pick up more of the material in the first list simply by dint of exposure. The "Grammar and Exercises" (GE) text is carefully coordinated with RG so that the student's grammatical knowledge grows apace as he encounters new structures in the reading passages. This is an ambitious text in some ways, but I do not think this is a negative. Grammar is well explained but advances rather rapidly (e.g., contract verbs are introduced immediately after presentation of "normal" verbs, imperatives are introduced, 1st- and 2nd-declension nouns and adjectives are presented...all in Chapter 1!), but the presentations are clear with multiple exercises to drill the student's mastery. If working without a teacher, I advise that the self-studier take his time. The chapters are rather long to begin with, and all will be well if the student simply paces himself reasonably. I do agree with another reviewer up to a point: those who are absolute beginners in language study will find the text challenging. Even a casual knowledge of another inflected language (e.g., Latin, Russian, or even German) will be immensely helpful, especially at the outset. As the author observed in his preface, the traditional classical education usually presumed a knowledge of Latin before the student embarked on Greek, but this is no longer so. Greek is a beautiful, marvelous language, but not an easy one, which is perhaps partly why the rewards for learning it are so great. Consistency and pacing are the key to progress. The "Independent Study Guide" mentioned above is extremely valuable. It not only presents good ideas for study but, most importantly, has a key to all the exercises as well as an English translation of all the reading passages. Even working with an experienced teacher in a classroom, the ISG is a huge help for the learner and should be purchased. There is also an audio CD of the reading passages. In all, an excellent and challenging text for the student who wants to make good strides towards reading real Classical Greek.
D**Z
Great book for actually reading.
If you're like me and you came from the soul-crushing world of pointless grammar-translation and are in the comprehensible input Copernican revolution, you'll love this book. I recommend it equally with Athenaze. Because language is primarily an auditory phenomenon, and language is learned via muscle memory and earworms (not via grammar -- just ask any child), you need to listen to it. So, either get the CDs too or do Athenaze + Luke Ranieri's YouTube channel to get the ancient sounds down. Then, read this one out loud. Staring at a text has very limited usefulness. There's a grammar book that comes with it, which can be helpful every few pages; but, your primary focus must be reading and training your brain to handle the onslaught of words. If you don't do that, you'll be in the pointless model of looking for subjects, verbs, modifiers, and parsing words -- which never works in the real world: "I'm sorry, can you repeat what you just said. I was looking for the subject." The progression in this book + Athenaze will train you to be OK to wait for the verb, subject, modifiers, etc. This is the primary skill needed in reading. Ignoring this is why some people call reading "advanced", when it's really the first step. Just read a clause (at normal speed). Didn't get it? Do it again (AT. NORMAL. SPEED). Let your brain do the heavy lifting. Don't know a word? This book has a super generous glossary with every block of text.
F**R
My favorite Greek course
I love this course. I learned Classical Greek in the 90s with Athenaze which is another inductive grammar. I have taught from deductive grammars as well as inductive grammars. The trouble with Athenaze and Reading Greek is the temptation to enjoy the stories and forget the grammar drills. This is especially the case with Reading Greek because the exercises and grammar are in a separate book. Students pick up a lot of vocabulary and grammar intuitively and one is tempted to think the classic drills are unnecessary. However my experience is that the level of knowledge obtainable in that way is limited. There will be large gaps in their knowledge. Grammar drills and exercises are essential. With that caveat in mind, Reading Greek is a pure delight to study and teach. Students enjoy reading extensive selections from day one. New grammar is illustrated in the narrative itself. Afterwards the teacher explains the grammar/new paradigms and follows up with drills and exercises. When students reread the narrative they do so with greater understanding. A warning about the digital version: there are extensive vocabulary lists adjacent to every narrative. A student’s eyes can easily hop between the vocabulary list and the reading selection. This is more difficult on an iPad or tablet and positively troublesome on an iPhone. This action flipping back and forth will disrupt the pace a new student can read. A student should only use a digital copy as a supplement to their hard copy. Incidentally, I believe this course is a great path to biblical Greek. The Greek art, mythology and ideas may be a turn-off to some individuals who only want to read the Bible. However, with Reading Greek, students learn words in their normal everyday context first. When the sacred/theological context is introduced later there can be a sense of illumination.
J**R
Great book, rubbish Kindle edition. Couldnt bother to type out the Greek. Miniscule image of text. Got this so I could study on the go. Mega ripoff.
A**S
The text, along with the Grammar and Exercises and the Independent Guide, is first class for the beginning student. Self-learners or high school students will love this.
古**徒
Text and Vocabulary、Grammar and Exercises、 Study Guide、CDの4つからなるReading GreekのシリーズのText and Vocabularyである。学習上、4つ揃えるのが望ましいのであろうが、新しい版では、TextにVocabularyが載っておらず文字通りTextだけであった初版と異なり、詳細なVocabularyが載っているので、文法は分かる、他に文法書は持っているという人の副読本として、十分に利用できる。何といっても、(別売だが)CDがシリーズに入っていて、耳から古典ギリシア語に親しめるのが有難い。私は、ウオークマンに入れて、しょっちゅう聴いている。 大量の古典ギリシア語の文章に触れたい、という人には、今や、一番のお勧めである。
C**N
This is a precious resource for people learning greek on their own. You can build up vocabulary step by step, and everything is explained very clearly. The only little downside is that you need to buy the other two books of the series to get everything you need, but that's alright, given the quality of the content. Recommended!
E**O
This is the best methodology to learn how to read Greek fluently in just one year!
Trustpilot
Hace 5 días
Hace 1 mes